Ever feel like the so-called “hidden gems” aren’t so hidden anymore? Me too. After 15 years of solo travel (and my fair share of crowded beaches), I’ve learned there are still islands out there that haven’t been overrun by tourist traps. These aren’t your Maldives or Santorinis—these are the quieter, underrated islands where you can still hear the waves without someone blaring music on a Bluetooth speaker. Let’s explore my favorite secret escapes—15 islands that will make you feel like you’ve stumbled into paradise before the masses catch on.
1. Flatey Island, Iceland
This tiny, picture-perfect island is like something out of a storybook. Think colorful cottages, puffins chilling on cliffs, and sunsets that stretch forever during summer. You won’t find souvenir shops here—just peace.
2. Siquijor, Philippines
Known locally as the “Island of Fire” (cue mysterious vibes), Siquijor is all about waterfalls, white-sand beaches, and locals who might just tell you a few witchcraft legends. Don’t skip Cambugahay Falls—seriously, it’s magical.
3. Isle of Eigg, Scotland
With a population of less than 100, Eigg is as offbeat as it gets. The island runs entirely on renewable energy, and hiking An Sgurr (its iconic peak) offers views that’ll leave you speechless. Oh, and no big crowds, just sheep and sea eagles.
4. Nisyros, Greece
Everyone flocks to Mykonos, but Nisyros? It’s an ancient volcanic island with cobblestone streets, natural hot springs, and a massive caldera you can hike into. I mean, who doesn’t want to say they walked into a volcano?
5. Koh Lipe, Thailand
It’s like Thailand’s version of the Maldives but without the luxury price tag. Clear waters, colorful coral reefs, and the kind of laid-back vibe where shoes are optional.
6. Iriomote Island, Japan
This is where Japan hides its jungles. Kayak through mangroves, hike to hidden waterfalls, and maybe spot the elusive Iriomote cat if you’re lucky. It’s raw and wild—just how I like my adventures.
7. Îles de la Madeleine, Canada
Tucked away in the Gulf of St. Lawrence, this archipelago has red cliffs, lighthouses, and seafood so fresh it’s still salty from the ocean. Bonus: you can go windsurfing without bumping into 50 other surfers.
8. São Jorge, Azores, Portugal
The Azores are getting buzzier, but São Jorge is still under the radar. It’s all about dramatic cliffs, volcanic craters, and cheese. Yes, cheese. Don’t leave without trying their famous queijo (thank me later).
9. Caye Caulker, Belize
The motto here is “Go Slow,” and it’s the vibe you never knew you needed. Rent a bike, snorkel with nurse sharks, and end your day with a rum punch and reggae music at The Split.
10. Marie-Galante, Guadeloupe
Think sugarcane fields, old windmills, and beaches so empty you might question if you’re in a dream. Plus, the rum here? Absolute perfection.
11. Chiloé Island, Chile
This quirky island is known for its colorful stilt houses and myths involving ghost ships. The seafood here is next-level, and the national parks? Oh, just some of the most magical forests I’ve ever seen.
12. Isla Holbox, Mexico
Picture an island where golf carts are the only vehicles. Add bioluminescent beaches at night, flamingos during the day, and some of the freshest ceviche ever. That’s Holbox for you.
13. Huahine, French Polynesia
Bora Bora who? Huahine is just as stunning but feels like a secret. Swim with rays, explore ancient temples, and enjoy an island untouched by mega-resorts.
14. Isle of Pines, New Caledonia
With its white sand beaches and tall pine trees, this island looks like something straight out of a dream. It’s so quiet you’ll hear your own heartbeat—perfect for a reset.
15. Anda, Bohol, Philippines
While everyone’s busy at Panglao, Anda is the underrated sibling. Hidden caves, untouched beaches, and snorkeling spots that rival anywhere in the world.
If you’re craving an escape from the overtouristed chaos, these 15 underrated islands are your ticket to paradise. They’ve stolen my heart and promise the kind of travel memories Instagram can’t capture (well, mostly). So pack light, go slow, and enjoy these slices of untouched heaven before everyone else finds out.